Countries are struggling to design rules to make shipping companies comply with a new bunker regulation designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, a senior International Bunker Industry Association official said Nov. 12, as Washington leads opposition to financial punitive measures.
International Maritime Organization member states, having failed to adopt the Net-Zero Framework as scheduled in October 2025, are due to meet again between Nov. 23 and Dec. 4 to discuss the regulation.
“People recognize that we need a GHG intensity marine fuel standard, and that is sort of generally agreed,” Edmund Hughes, IBIA’s representative to the UN agency, told Platts. “The sticking point is on the financial aspects.”
In its current form, the framework is composed of GHG intensity thresholds for marine energy that tighten progressively over 2028-2035, and financial costs for shipping companies failing to meet the standards.
But the US has fiercely opposed what it describes as “a global carbon tax” on shipping for the financial element, and a growing number of member states have proposed various revisions to the framework in bids to achieve a compromise.
“That is where we have the trouble. Because, obviously, the member states haven’t been able to identify the best approach,” Hughes said on the sidelines of the IBIA Annual Convention 2026.
Compliance mechanism
Countries supporting the current net-zero framework have designed the financial element to promote the use of low-carbon marine fuels, which remain much more costly than conventional, oil-based fuels due to limited availability.
October’s average delivered bunker costs for 0.5%-sulfur fuel oil are $22.78 per gigajoule in Singapore, compared with $27/GJ for bioblend B24, $28.48/GJ for LNG, and $48.47/GJ for 100% sustainable methanol, according to the Platts global bunker cost calculator.
“No shipping company is going to carry on buying more expensive fuel while their competitors are not,” Hughes said. “You need some way of closing that price gap.”
The IBIA official said challenges lie ahead for member states on how to design an alternative compliance mechanism if the current net-zero framework is to be revised.
Most Pacific Island states and EU member states are officially still supporting the current net-zero framework while the US and Middle Eastern states remain opposed to it. Japan, China, Norway and some major flag states have presented new ideas on compliance mechanisms.
“If you have a technical standard, you have to find a way to comply with it,” Hughes said. “You can go through quite a few semantic gymnastics to try and get the agreement, and that’s often what’s done at international level in multilateral discussions.”
Outlook
IBIA, the world’s largest trade association representing bunker industry participants, including bunker traders and fuel suppliers, has been granted consultative status with the IMO and its representatives regularly participate in IMO meetings.
“We recognize and value, as a sector, having global rules,” Hughes said. “That helps in all sorts of aspects in terms of understanding what the compliance requirements are, understanding what the market needs, what we need to provide in terms of fuels, and what people want to buy.”
Going forward, Hughes said IMO member states may need to coalesce around a net-zero framework in a return to its tradition of consensus building so future implementation could be ensured globally.
In April 2025, a total of 63 countries won a vote to approve the framework’s current text after the US withdrew from the negotiations. Later, 57 countries won another vote to delay its adoption in October 2025.
“There was a vote… that already sent a clear signal that there was no consensus,” Hughes said. “The people who win a vote might think they won, but they [actually] lost.”




